Iran has effectively won the war that was started against them by the United States and Israel. The people who were killed and those close to them obviously didn’t win. But in terms of state vs. state, Iran won.
All you have to do is look at the so-called Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). For the parts in the MoU that Iran has to fulfill, Iranian officials were already willing to do before the war started.
For the parts of the MoU that the U.S. state must fulfill, they are above and beyond anything that would have been considered before the war started.
Some of the MoU is similar to the JCPOA, which Trump tore up during his first term in office. Primarily, Iran must get inspections to ensure they are not building a nuclear weapon.
The things that are different are all in Iran’s favor. Iran will somehow get $300 billion, which is likely more than their entire economy produces in a single year. Iran will control the Strait of Hormuz and will likely continue to collect tolls or fees or whatever you want to call them. In addition, U.S. forces are supposed to withdraw from the immediate region, although we don’t know what that specifically means. To top it off, Israel is supposed to withdraw from Lebanon.
Now, you may say that this won’t go through and the Israelis won’t abide by the agreement. Maybe the U.S. won’t abide either. But then why did Trump ever come to any such agreement in the first place? If it was just to give time to replenish missiles and military power, it just shows how weak and unprepared the military was for this adventure.
If it falls through just because Israel sabotages the deal, it still shows that Trump was essentially forced to admit defeat without actually saying so.
Reality Hits
Some kind of mature adult must have finally gotten Trump’s ear. Maybe it was Vance, but who knows. Trump must have been told that the U.S. bases in the region have sustained significant damage. He must have been told that there is no way for the U.S. military to effectively open up the Strait of Hormuz, which was always open prior to this foolish war. Trump must have been told that the war is unpopular with the American people and that this misadventure will get the blame for any kind of economic recession.
Many of us saw this reality when the war started, or even before the war started. Iran had already demonstrated its missile power in 2025 when Israel (and then the United States) attacked it.
When people talk about how Iran is winning the war, this is sometimes portrayed as people cheering for Iran. But it is really just facing reality.
If your friend is driving 100 mph towards a cliff, and he says he is headed towards Disney World, it doesn’t mean you are cheering for bad things to happen just because you point out that there is a cliff ahead. It is dealing in reality.
Cheering for Iran?
Aside from the reality, some people in the West really are cheering for Iran. But this doesn’t make one a traitor to the U.S. It doesn’t make someone anti American. Also, it really isn’t cheering for the Iranian state. It is cheering against people who initiate war.
It isn’t the American people losing with an Iranian win. The American people are losers for the war ever starting, just as the Iranian people are. But most Americans, other than a tiny few military personnel, are not physically hurt in any way by the war. That isn’t quite as true for Israelis.
The American people are losers in terms of lost liberty and a lower standard of living than they would have otherwise had. But that is because of the war being started.
If anything, Iran essentially winning the war and holding the cards in the negotiations is a win for the American people because it is a defeat for the evil establishment in the United States.
Donald Trump deserves to go down in history as a horrible president and a horrible person. The neocons that he cozied up to deserve to be known as a bunch of losers and cowards. Most of all, they all deserve to be known as evil.
The Benefits to the American People of an Iranian Win
Imagine if this attack against Iran had been successful from the viewpoint of Trump and his war hawk advisors.
We saw what happened after Venezuela was a seeming cakewalk. Trump was ready to take over the world. Let’s remember Canada and Greenland. They are still talking about Cuba even with the humiliating defeat in Iran.
Trump, Netanyahu, and the war hawks were ready to take over the entire Middle East and then some. Paying $300 billion to Iran seems like a bargain to the American people to get out of this thing.
The American people win when the U.S. empire is weakened. The American people win when the establishment suffers humiliation. In this sense, an Iranian win in this war is actually something of a victory for the American people.
The war should have never happened in the first place. But since we have a bunch of evil people in charge of foreign policy, it did happen. The bullies finally got put in their place for once.
In order to understand the winners and losers, you have to differentiate between the people and the government.
The enemy of the American people is not the Iranian state. The enemy of the American people, whether they realize it or not, is their own government, particularly when it comes to foreign policy. When the government loses, the people tend to win. That is because the average person benefits when the state that rules over them loses some power.
This is not always true, but we need to stop thinking of the state as “we the people”. Our interests are not the same as Donald Trump, Joe Biden, or Marco Rubio. In many cases, they are the exact opposite.